Shopping Cart
Your Cart is Empty
There was an error with PayPalClick here to try again
CelebrateThank you for your business!You should be receiving an order confirmation from Paypal shortly.Exit Shopping Cart



Safety first !



Ultrasonic Testing vs. Magnetic Particle Inspection: When to Use UT Over MPI

Posted on October 1, 2020 at 5:40 PM

The market for nondestructive testing (NDT) in North America is increasing rapidly, with similar growth around the world. There are two reasons for this: nondestructive testing works for nearly every industry, and there is a wide variety of NDT techniques for nearly every inspection need.


With the use of NDT being so widespread, there are techniques that perform better in comparison to others. Two of the most popular are ultrasonic testing (UT) and magnetic particle inspection (MPI).


In this article, we look at ultrasonic testing vs. magnetic particle inspection—the benefits, drawbacks, and when to use each.

Magnetic Particle Inspection


Magnetic Particle Inspection (sometimes referred to as Magnetic Particle Testing) is a very common and easy-to-use NDT technique. It works, as its name applies, by having the tester create a magnetic field around the object being inspected. This is done with a permanent or electromagnet, induced magnetic field (such as from a current-carrying coil) or by a direct electrical current run through the object.


The object being tested is then coated with tiny iron particles. The current magnetizes the particles to the surface, revealing any flaws.

The Benefits of Magnetic Particle Inspection


While this might seem complicated, it is actually pretty simple and easy-to-use. It is fast, can be inexpensive, and many MPI instruments are portable.


MPI is considered much more accurate, effective, and efficient than inspections that use dye penetrants. MPI is excellent at detecting flaws on the surface of objects.

The Drawbacks of Magnetic Particle Inspection


Likely the biggest drawback of MPI is that it has a much more limited use for subsurface flaws or cracks. It is not particularly effective when it comes to measuring the height or depth of a surface crack (length and width only). This leads to inspectors receiving only a partial view of the potential issue.


Another drawback is that it is, essentially, subjective. It relies on the interpretation of the inspector, leaving room for human error. The readings can also be inaccurate if the magnetic field is not perfectly aligned.


While MPI is easy-to-use, it can only be used on ferromagnetic materials—materials that can be magnetized. They have to be clean and unpainted, and then they have to be demagnetized afterward.


In fact, due to these drawbacks, many are now looking at Eddy Current Array (ECA) testing as a replacement option vs. MPI for surface and subsurface flaw detection. ECA offers a fast, easy to use technique with no extensive surface preparation and a complete record of inspection.

Ultrasonic Testing


Ultrasonic testing is one of the original NDT techniques, dating back to the 1950s. Since then, technology has evolved to the point where the original UT techniques would likely be unrecognizable, but the principle remains the same.


In ultrasonic testing, a transducer is manually moved over an object. The transducer introduces high-frequency sound waves into the material and hollow spots—tiny cracks, hairline fissures, microscopic pocks—create an echo.


These soundwaves are used to create a full 3D image of the object, allowing the user to objectively see where the flaws are and how deep they might run.


There are many types of UT, including phased array, straight beam, angled beam, time of flight diffraction (TOFD), and guided wave. Phased array and TOFD are the most common and trusted. The versatility and efficiency of UT have contributed greatly to the growth of NDT worldwide.

The Benefits of Ultrasonic Testing


Speed. Reliability. Versatility. There’s a reason this is one of the most frequently used methods. Unlike some other methods, UT is portable, can go under the surface, penetrating objects dense or large, to find flaws that would be invisible to the naked eye and hidden from other types of testing. It is ideal for volumetric inspections and easily handles complex geometries.


Many of today’s phased array UT offerings can provide a true 3D image, created in real-time for immediate results. This allows inspectors to objectively analyze the full thickness of the object by looking at a screen; the image can be downloaded and shared for others to do the same. This allows someone to visualize the object of inspection without having to be physically present.


Another benefit of UT is the ability to record inspection results and compare them over time. This allows inspectors to understand how different materials react to different environments and pressures.

The Drawbacks of Ultrasonic Testing


While UT has a host of benefits, there is one thing to consider: the need for human guidance. The transducer still needs a human to perform. The incredibly accurate results are partly the result of the operator knowing just how to angle the path of the signal. While getting full coverage is easy, this still requires training.


The reliability and ease of this system come from a few pieces of instrumentation, along with the scanners, the software, and the different probes and wedges. Accurate, 3D results require a certain level of complexity.

Ultrasonic Testing vs. Magnetic Particle Inspection: Which Is Right For You?


Over the last few years, more and more industries have begun to change their NDT techniques. For example, austenitic stainless steel makers have made the shift from radiography to ultrasonic. While many techniques may be able to detect flaws, not all technology is created equal. Like in the case of ultrasonic testing, magnetic particle inspection, and eddy current testing, one technique may work better than another depending on the application.


When considering which technique best suits your needs, the key is to weigh the advantages and disadvantages, examine your budget, understand the costs of the most accurate tests, and then make a decision. When accuracy matters, NDT testing is more an investment than an expense. It is also a hedge against downtime, non-compliance, and potential safety hazards.

Categories: Non - Destructive Testing

Post a Comment


Oops, you forgot something.


The words you entered did not match the given text. Please try again.


Reply novaapk
7:22 PM on June 25, 2022 
philadelphia eagles army hat ray ban coloured sunglasses moncler sparkle jacket shiny black moncler jacket air jordan 2011 red and hvit nike air max triple white
Reply blturnerintl
8:08 PM on June 24, 2022 
ray ban clubround replacement lenses moncler fragment mayconne santos fc kit romo color rush jersey milwaukee bucks blue jersey
Reply namasedu
8:07 PM on June 24, 2022 
mens softride rift slip on sneaker under armour phantom sneakers dwyane wade nike miami heat youth vice nights swingman jersey plus size mini skater dress pandora 180892cz dkny abbi sneakers
Reply technotizie
6:10 PM on June 24, 2022 
red bottoms jimmy choo grey suede red bottoms miami dolphins shoes reebok for cheap nike air flight 89 chicago all star soft cashmere knit beanie oakley holbrook black green
Reply tertogel
4:22 PM on June 24, 2022 
parma fc burberry blue label small bag marc jacobs babydoll dress midi dress semi formal moncler style puffer jacket coach bleecker mini riley
Reply smileytips
2:33 PM on June 24, 2022 
arsenal soccer pants love tiffany bracelet light pink evening gown best slim iphone 11 pro case mizuno energy wave sky 4 lids army hat
Reply cindenyolla
2:32 PM on June 24, 2022 
air max react 270 orange nike zoom 2k white pink athletech sleeveless shirts gortons fisherman islanders jersey brendan shanahan rangers jersey puma axis trainers
Reply caralarma
7:34 AM on June 24, 2022 
adidas superstar foundation junior black full sleeve gown for girls dior phone case iphone 12 pro silver white wedding dress party hat 1 billionaire boy outfits
Reply lqamaalfkihf
6:58 AM on June 24, 2022 
Reply nospinw
1:46 AM on June 24, 2022 
nike green golf cap long sleeve vintage tee coach crossbody dufflette adidas edge lux mens air jordan reveal all pink chris paul tee
Reply reidmanor
11:15 PM on June 23, 2022 
mens alexander mcqueen trainers sale nike dri fit hat ebay zion 1 grey adidas zx 500 originals bloomings poloshirt lakers 4t
Reply classfaqs
11:14 PM on June 23, 2022 
air max react 270 orange nike zoom 2k white pink athletech sleeveless shirts gortons fisherman islanders jersey brendan shanahan rangers jersey puma axis trainers
Reply nardulan
3:07 PM on June 23, 2022 
arsenal soccer pants love tiffany bracelet light pink evening gown best slim iphone 11 pro case mizuno energy wave sky 4 lids army hat
Reply solarmedium
2:27 PM on June 23, 2022 
coach new york locations lululemon day to night dress black supreme air force 1 usc football jersey custom coach disney wallet mens the north face womens metropolis iii down parka
Reply tlclease
11:13 AM on June 23, 2022 
adidas ultraboost 20 limited edition womens salute to service steelers hoodie for cheap red satin dress long sleeve pandora solitaire huggie hoop earrings cincinnati reds 1990 hat xlt mizuno volleyball shoes wave lightning z5
Reply fociphotos
11:13 AM on June 23, 2022 
adidas superstar foundation junior black full sleeve gown for girls dior phone case iphone 12 pro silver white wedding dress party hat 1 billionaire boy outfits
Reply Feemalk
9:47 AM on June 23, 2022 
Ezhcey Vasotec - Cialis Jpwnpb Lungs are almost always involved. Cialis Lradso These practitioners learned to select and prepare herbs to carry out ceremonies to employ tokens charms and offerings to make intimate contact with nature and to read signs and symbols from the spirits. - Cialis Obshqh
Reply fayamatt
8:10 PM on June 22, 2022 
cincinnati reds memorial day hat operations nike shox gravity mens all white shoes yeezy boost 350 price quotation toronto blue jays realtree camo hat viet xa pro v8 mid mens sun hats john lewis
Reply piarnet
4:58 PM on June 22, 2022 
82 cowboys jersey backless dress fashion nova youth 9forty chelsea news kit for cheap gatorade 6s for sale plus size kurtis online usa
Reply jXAhlnQJCguF
12:54 PM on June 22, 2022